Sgt. Peffer's Cafe Italian

Sgt. Peffer's Cafe Italian in Omaha, NE, is a captivating destination for lovers of authentic Northern Italian cuisine and hearty, handcrafted pizzas. Nestled at 1501 N Saddle Creek Rd, this charming eatery offers an inviting atmosphere that strikes the perfect balance between casual comfort and intimate dining, making it ideal for family dinners, dates, or a relaxed gathering with friends.

Step inside and prepare to indulge your senses with a menu that reads like an ode to classic Italian flavors, elevated with careful attention to freshness and quality. Whether you crave the velvety embrace of the Creamy Chicken Alfredo, the rich and satisfying layers of their Seafood Lasagna featuring shrimp and crab, or the light, crispy allure of the Five Cheese White Pizza, every dish is crafted to delight.

Seafood enthusiasts will revel in specialties like the Creamy Clams—tender clams bathed in a luscious parmesan sauce—or the Red Clam Pasta where savory clams are sautéed in olive oil with a hint of spice from red and black pepper, garlic, and fresh parsley. Vegetarians and cheese lovers won't be disappointed by Quattroformaggi, a decadent blend of bleu cheese, parmesan, provolone, and romano melted into a silky sauce that clings lovingly to each tender pasta strand.

For those seeking a heartier meal, the baked casseroles are standout options. Try the Scampi & Artichokes, which marries succulent shrimp with the delicate earthiness of artichoke hearts in a buttery garlic sauce over linguini, or the Chicken Parmesan, a flawless combination of tangy pomarola, mozzarella, and parmesan cheeses baked to gooey perfection. The Sherry Cream Mushroom Chicken is another decadent highlight, offering a creamy bourguignon-inspired flavor with mushrooms and rich parmesan that lingers satisfyingly on the palate.

Pizza lovers are raving about Sgt. Peffer's pies—from classic options like the New Yorker and Meat Pizza to unique favorites such as the Frankenzza. Crisply baked crusts topped with generous, flavorful ingredients make each slice a savory experience worth savoring. Accompany your meal with starters like Mozzarella Sticks or BBQ Meatballs, and don’t miss a bowl of their flavorful Mushroom or Minestrone Soup served with homemade rolls.

Customer experiences underscore the genuine care and quality that set Sgt. Peffer's apart. David Cloyed shared how the spaghetti and meatballs was the perfect size for his date night, emphasizing the tenderness of the meatballs and the attentive, knowledgeable service that enhanced the evening. Meanwhile, pitterpaw hailed it as the best Italian food in town, particularly noting the Chicken Florentine soup as the most delicious they've ever had. Pizza aficionados like Jason Royer highlight it as a must-stop for seriously good pies that will not disappoint.

The friendly and attentive staff bring warmth to the experience, even when initial wait times occur, as Lena Falkner found, the service quickly made up for any delays. Tsan Diltz-Rydel’s note on the convenient takeout experience, while humorous about the hidden napkins, speaks to the thoughtful packaging that accompanies meals for a perfect picnic by the park.

In every bite and each visit, Sgt. Peffer's Cafe Italian captures the heart of Northern Italian cooking with a welcoming vibe that invites guests to relax and savor. Whether you are craving the familiar comfort of spaghetti and meatballs, the robust flavors of baked casseroles, or a perfectly crafted pizza, this Omaha gem consistently delivers authentic, flavorful Italian cuisine with a side of genuine hospitality.

For reservations or takeout orders, call +1 402-558-7717 and treat yourself to an unforgettable Italian dining experience that feels like a warm embrace from Italy itself.